Fourteen governments, including the U.S., Britain and France, endorsed the first guidelines for companies that develop, sell or finance commercial hacking tools, The Record reported Wednesday. The voluntary standard gives buyers, investors and export regulators a common yardstick for judging spyware and hack-for-hire vendors, though fewer than half of the countries at the meeting signed it.
What Happened
The guidelines were adopted at the third conference of the Pall Mall Process, a diplomatic initiative led by Britain and France to curb the spread and abuse of what governments call commercial cyber intrusion capabilities: tools and services, sold by private firms, that let a customer secretly break into phones, computers or networks. Representatives of 43 countries attended, according to The Record. It listed Britain, France, the U.S., Germany, Italy and Japan among the 14 endorsing governments, did not name the remaining signatories or the countries that declined, and said it was unclear why the others held back.
Under the guidelines, companies should vet their customers, build technical safeguards against misuse, and keep systems for monitoring and reporting abuse. They should stop sales and support when there is a credible risk of serious misuse, and "consider" remedies for victims of human rights abuses.
The text is non-binding, creates no new international legal obligations and carries no penalties, The Record reported. The French Foreign Ministry described it as the first global standard of responsible conduct for the sector and added, as quoted by The Record, "A voluntary code is not, however, an optional code." Britain's Foreign Office said the aim is to discourage irresponsible activity across the market and give regulators, vendors and customers more transparency.
Why It Matters
Because the guidelines cover financing as well as development and sales, they reach private equity owners, venture investors and lenders, not only the vendors. That matters as the industry seeks public capital: The Primary Wire reported in September, citing The Record, that Paragon Solutions, maker of the Graphite spyware, plans to list on Nasdaq through a merger with a blank-check company.
With no enforcement mechanism, pressure on vendors is expected to come from governments that buy these tools and license their export, according to The Record. U.S. endorsement means American firms that sell intrusion tools or services to government customers, at home or abroad, may face questions about customer vetting and misuse monitoring framed by this standard.
The stakes reach well beyond the vendors. The French ministry said the tools have been tied to surveillance of journalists, political officials, activists and businesses. The Primary Wire reported this month, citing The Record, that Apple had warned users in 99 countries they may have been targeted with commercial spyware.
Context
The Pall Mall Process began in London in 2024. Its launch drew large technology and cybersecurity companies but not the controversial firms linked to abuses, The Record reported. Last year's conference produced the Code of Practice for States, a voluntary set of recommendations for governments acting as regulators, customers and users of such tools, which 27 countries have since signed, according to The Record.
The effort has drawn skepticism. Participants raised concerns in 2025 that it cannot change how the tools are actually traded and used, and some have noted that Britain and France seek to limit other states' access while promoting their own spyware industries, The Record reported.
What to Watch
The first test is whether more of the 43 attending countries endorse the guidelines, and whether signatories write them into export licensing or procurement terms. The French ministry said participants will keep working as artificial intelligence, automation and new business models raise fresh questions for the market. Investors should also watch whether vendors heading to public markets, such as Paragon's planned listing, cite the guidelines in their disclosures.